New Delhi. After
losing out to China in much of the South Asian region and elsewhere, India may
have just about pre-empted the more powerful and aggressive neighbour in Bhutan.
Bhutan is crucial for the obvious geophysical location between
India and China. It has not been hostile like Pakistan or Bangladesh, nor has
it made a policy of maintaining an equidistance as Nepal has done between India
and China. The principal reason has been the presence of a century-old monarchy
and Bhutans isolation from much of the world. India has remained the principal
gateway. But things are changing, what with the enlightened monarchy itself
organizing elections to usher in the worlds newest democracy in the Himalayan
kingdom. And it was just as well that within weeks, Prime Minister Manmohan
Singh paid a two-day visit mid-May. He held talks with the previous king,
Jigme Singye Wangchuk, and his son and the present monarch, 28-year-old Jigme
Khesar Namgyal Wangchuk. Before discussing the visit, there is need for
a flashback to December 2003 to underline Bhutans importance for Indias
internal security. New Delhi approached the then monarch for help in flushing
out fugitive rebels from the Indian northeast, belonging to various militant organisations,
operating from Bhutan. Donning the military fatigue, the monarch himself
led the Bhutanese security forces and conducted a cleansing operation. At least
600 were caught and handed over to India and many more hundreds fled to Bhutanese
territory. The Operation All Clear was a success. It is
another matter that this splendid gesture was not effectively followed by India
and the militants escaped to Bangladesh and Myanmar, or melted away in the Indian
northeastern region. Mercifully, the Indian PMs visit was fairly well-publicized
in contrast with the election coverage by the Indian media that is forever preoccupied
with Hollywood and Bollywood, and ready to lap up what the international media
has to say about things in its neighbourhood. Unfortunately,
very few newspapers dispatched correspondents to report the historic elections,
while the rest depended upon the international wire services.
India has
enjoyed an advantage having taken care of Bhutans security under the 1949
Friendship Treaty and secured its support on regional and international issues.
It is just appropriate that India revised this treaty last year, giving greater
scope and movement for Bhutan. There has always been understanding in fact
between the two neighbours, and the revision in favour of Bhutan should help consolidate
it further. After the elections, Bhutans leadership is now a combination
of the benign, enlightened monarchy and an elected legislature of 47 members.
It wants to reach out to the world. India can help in that
indeed, India is best placed for this. Hence, it was most appropriate that
at the political level, as Dr Manmohan Singh pointed out, the updated India-Bhutan
Friendship Treaty gave Thimphu more freedom in international diplomacy and nonlethal
military purchases. It was a watershed event, keeping in mind that India supports
the Bhutanese economy to a considerable extent. The Indian Prime Minister
in fact announced a whopping Rs 100 billion ($ 2.5 billion) economic package over
the next five years, and did so while addressing the new Bhutanese Parliament. This
is one of the biggest economic packages, if not the biggest, that India has promised
another country, the importance of which cannot be minimized. He also utilized
the occasion to announce the building of Bhutans first rail link connecting
Hashimara to Phuentsholing, called the Golden Jubilee Rail Line, linking Bhutan
with the entire railway network of India, which is one of the largest in the world. Most
of all, it would provide Bhutan access to the Indian ports for its foreign trade.
Dr Manmohan Singh was the first foreign leader to address Bhutans
national Assembly. He made it amply clear that India supported Bhutans
transition from a kingdom to the worlds youngest democracy. As
Bhutan enters a new era in its history, you can continue to count on India as
a friend. As we enter a new era in our ties and a new century, I come to seek
and reinforce the same meeting of minds. He pointed out to vast opportunities
that the Indian market offered for Bhutans agriculture, industry and service
sectors. India imports a substantial quantity of food products and electricity
from Bhutan but there is scope for the Himalayan kingdom to produce more and for
India to absorb much more. For this tranquil country of less than 650,000
people that still prides in sticking by the concept of prioritising Gross National
Happiness (GNH) over Gross Domestic Product (GDP), education and healthcare are
free and most villages have water and electricity. But there are problems
as unemployment, especially in the rural hinterland is rising, and a huge swathe
of the population still lives below the poverty line. The
Indian PM outlined a future roadmap where more could be achieved. India
and Bhutan are well placed to create a new paradigm for inter-governmental cooperation
in the areas of water security and environmental integrity.
We know
we are on the right path when electricity generated in the mountains and valleys
of Chukha, Kurichhu and Tala lights homes in Bihar, West Bengal and Delhi and
generates wealth for Bhutan, he said. He also announced a significant
move to broaden Indias own energy basket by pledging to import 10,000 MW
of electricity by 2020 from Bhutan, a country with one of the worlds largest
hydropower potentials. Selling power to India means more money, more funds
for development for Bhutan, a point that has been driven home ever since Bhutans
electricity joined the Indian power grid two years ago. Following his address
, Dr Manmohan Singh dedicated the Tala project, built with Indias assistance,
to Bhutan and laid the foundation of the 1,095 MW Punatsangchhu hydroelectric
project. We will commence the preparation of detailed project reports
for four new projects, he announced, adding that implementation of these
projects will help achieve the target of at least 5,000 MW of electricity from
Bhutan to India by 2020. Dr Manmohan Singh also offered to strengthen Indo-Bhutanese
ties with institutional linkages between the judiciary, election commissions and
other constitutional bodies. While doing so, he also took the opportunity
of driving some home truths about how to make a functioning democracy before his
Bhutanese audience. He pointed out that the ability to accommodate dissent
and show tolerance to the others point of view are some of the crucial elements
to make a democracy work. We do know that democracy is not merely
about holding elections. Democracy requires sustained commitment to tolerance
and the judicious exercise of power as a societal trust to be used for public
good. It requires a deep commitment to the rule of law. It requires the
building of strong institutions of governance and respect for the others
viewpoint. |