Top News
|China warns against turning Nvidia Jensen Huang affair with Chinese friend Alice Huang as a Spy Scandal | Alice, accused of Stealing Tech Secrets, out of US in China under State protection | Future Wars will be Won by Technology, not Jets alone, Rajnath Singh tells IAF Commanders | Air Pollution kills 2 million in India, affects 660 people, and costs $95 b annually, warns FICCI, India’s oldest industry body | Delhi Air Quality ‘Very Poor’ even a week after Diwali | As farmers burn stubble, UP Govt initiates steps to recycle it to prevent pollution | Supreme Court asks four northern States around Delhi to curb stubble burning farm fires, and Polluting vehicles | India Pushes for Ukraine Peace, seeks Secure Seas, Grain and Energy Flow | Trump says New Strikes on Iran Not Needed | Industry Minister Piyush Goyal invites MnCs to ‘Make India Your Address’ for Manufacturing and Technology Ops | Bomb threats by terrorists force 11 passenger aircraft across Europe to divert | Tata Motors seeks controling stake in Italian commercial vehicle maker Iveco | Tata Sons Chairman Chandrasekaran meets Italian PM Giorgia Meloni | Indigenous Defence Production imperative for Defence Production | Supreme Court Rules: That the Indian Constitution has Supremacy over Special Laws | That The Right to Speedy Trial is Fundamental, and Cannot be Violated to Deny Bail | And that Protesters Cannot Justify Endless occupation of any site | Restoring Fighter Aircraft Strength Foremost Task, says ACM Ashutosh Dixit after taking over as Air Chief | India’s Haryana State makes Digital ID compulsory for Doctors, Nurses and Pharmacists | Saudi Defence Minister Prince Khalif bin Sultan, Pak Army Chief Field Marshal Asim Munir and Director of Turkish Intelligence Ibrahim Kalin visit Teheran Oct 26 for peace talks | They are meeting President Masoud Pezeshkian and Secretary of Supreme National Security Council Mohsen Rezaei | UAE nominates Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Lana Zaki Nussiebeh to be the next UN Secretary General | A career diplomat, the Cambridge-educated Lana was UAE’s Ambassador at the UN for a decade, playing a key role in getting Security Council membership for her country | Born in 1978 in Abu Dhabi, Lana supported the Abraham Accords on behalf of the UAE, and UAE’s Relations with Israel | Lana has deep roots in Palestine, and her Grandfather and Father both played lead roles in Diplomacy in Jordan and UAE | Trump waives Sanctions on India and China for Buying Russian Oil | And US itself buys 3.8 million tonnes of Diesel from Russia with Trump himself calling Putin for the deal | Air India, Indigo and Akasa suspend flights to Saudi Arabia due to Houthi attacks on Airports | India’Trump waives Sanctions on India and China for Buying Russian Oil | And US itself buys 3.8 million tonnes of Diesel from Russia with Trump himself calling Putin for the deal | Air India, Indigo and Akasa suspend flights to Saudi Arabia due to Houthi attacks on Airports | India Condemns Attacks on Saudi Civilian Airports, Ports and Refineries | India’s Space Economy could Grow from $9b now to $40 billion in 10 years, says Space Minister Jitendra Singh | India developing Integrated Defence Logistics for Army, Navy and Air Force |
Uncategorized

Delhi High Court Upholds IAF’s Refusal to Disclose PM’s Flight Records

New Delhi. The Delhi High Court has overturned a Central Information Commission (CIC) directive requiring the Indian Air Force (IAF) to release flight records linked to foreign trips undertaken by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and former Prime Minister Dr Manmohan Singh. The court held that disclosure of the documents could expose sensitive security arrangements and potentially endanger the Prime Minister.

AI generated Image

Justice Amit Mahajan ruled in favour of the Central Public Information Officer (CPIO) at the Directorate of Personnel Services, Air Headquarters, affirming the IAF’s decision to withhold the records under Sections 8(1)(a) and 8(1)(g) of the Right to Information (RTI) Act, which provide exemptions for information that could affect national security or endanger individuals.

The court found that the CIC had not adequately considered the security implications when it ordered the disclosure of Special Flight Returns (SFR-II). It observed that even if the names and identifying details of security personnel were removed, other information contained in the documents could still expose sensitive operational details.

Justice Mahajan noted that the use of public money for the Prime Minister’s overseas travel did not automatically make the associated records available for public scrutiny if their release could jeopardise security arrangements.

The ruling quashes the CIC’s order of July 8, 2020, which had instructed the IAF to provide certified copies of relevant SFR-II records relating to foreign visits by Modi and Manmohan Singh on IAF aircraft.

The matter originated in an RTI application submitted by retired Commodore Lokesh K Batra on June 5, 2018. He sought details of foreign travel undertaken by Indian Prime Ministers aboard IAF aircraft from April 1, 2013, up to the date of his application. In its initial response, the Air Force provided some information concerning Modi’s overseas travel. It also stated that Manmohan Singh had not travelled on IAF aircraft between April 1, 2013, and May 25, 2014.

However, the Air Force declined to provide copies of Special Flight Returns, Parts I and II, citing the sensitive and confidential nature of the documents. According to the IAF, the records contained information relating to aircraft, crew members, passengers and Special Protection Group (SPG) personnel assigned to the Prime Minister’s security detail. The service argued that these details, when assessed alongside information already available publicly, could help reveal aspects of the security arrangements for overseas visits.

After the First Appellate Authority dismissed Batra’s appeal in September 2018, he approached the CIC. The commission subsequently directed the Air Force to disclose the available and relevant SFR-II records, prompting the IAF to challenge the decision before the Delhi High Court.

During the proceedings, the Air Force maintained that the records contained multiple interconnected details, including the designations and appointments of passengers, identification numbers, flight references, passenger numbers and information about the agencies involved. Even without direct identifiers, it argued, these details could be pieced together to identify security personnel, establish the composition of the Prime Minister’s travelling party and infer patterns in security deployment.

Batra’s counsel contended that the information related to overseas travel financed by taxpayers and was therefore of considerable public interest. The counsel also argued that the application sought information about private individuals accompanying the Prime Minister at public expense, rather than the identities of security personnel.

The High Court, however, found that the use of public funds alone was insufficient to justify disclosure of information carrying potential security risks. It concluded that the case did not establish a sufficiently compelling larger public interest to override the applicable exemptions under the RTI Act.

Related Articles

Back to top button